萌新，关于理智鉴定大失败的问题

[fallenfire]

规则7th，想问下大失败大成功有没有不适用的地方，之前跑的时候有个说法是sancheck没有大失败这一说法，失败了就是失败。但是我看规则书上大失败的举例里就有理智检定，同时查询大失败和理智检定的词条中没标明不适用大失败，请问具体是有没有啊。

[萧永念]

没有通常意义上的大失败，也许应该这么讲？
理智丧失的大失败就是很单纯的数值拉满，不会造成“由KP决定的不幸后果”

[tangys]

2. 理智检定(Sanity Roll)大失败如何处理?
    理智检定大失败时, 自动受到最大理智损失.
    例如Sanity Lose 2/2D10+1, 如若理智检定大失败，则理智值损失21点.

    规则书速查->第五章-游戏系统-5.5 大失败与大成功
   

劇透 -   :

A Sanity roll where the cost is 2/2D10+1 means a fumble failure (“100” rolled) would mean the loss of 21 Sanity points maximum (1D10 + 1D10 + 1 = 10 + 10 + 1 = 21). If the rolled was failed but not a fumble then the loss would be rolled as 1D10 + 1D10 + 1 (resulting in a loss between 3 to 21, depending on the outcomes of the two dice rolls). Basically, Sanity losses are written as "X / Y” - X = the loss for a successful roll, while the number or dice roll after the slash (”Y”) is the loss for a failed roll. See page 154 of the Rulebook:

"In published Call of Cthulhu scenarios, Sanity loss rolls are shown as two numbers or rolls separated by a slash, for instance: SAN 1/1D4+1. The number to the left of the slash is the number of Sanity points lost if the Sanity roll succeeds. The die roll to the right of the slash is the number of Sanity points lost if the Sanity roll is failed.

至于大成功或者大失败有没有不适用的地方，成长判定是明确不适用的。此外，临时疯狂后的智力检定，可能也不适用（但这个是我个人观点）